Equine Navicular Disease has many names, including Navicular Syndrome, caudle heel pain as well as podotrochleosis. The condition is all too common to many horse owners, unfortunately, and can significantly impact performance, general movement and overall quality of life due to pain generally located in the heel region of the front feet. Navicular Syndrome can be difficult to manage, especially in the advanced stage, but through a combination of approaches, including nutrion and herbs, the outcome for the patient can be improved.
To understand a disease, one must first understand general anatomy. The navicular bone is located on the palmar or caudle aspect of all four feet in the horse, generally located between the heel bulbs. Let’s look at a couple of standard x-rays which demonstrate the location.
The image to the left is what is termed a lateral view of thefoot or distal limb. In this image, I have the navicular bone pointed out with a yellow arrow. As you can see, it is generally located between the pastern and coffin bone on the back aspect of the foot. What you cannot see in this x-ray is the placement of the flexor tendons, which are thought to contribute to the pain encountered as well as potential deterioration of the condition. The main tendon that is of interest is the Deep Digital Flexor Tendon (DDFT), which courses down the back of the limb, overtop of the navicular bone and then attaches the bottom of the coffin bone. More on this tendon in a bit and influences upon motion.
In the image to the right, we have what is termed an AP view of the navicular bone.
The beam of the x-ray is targeted on the top aspect of the junction between the coffin bone and the pastern bone. Hopefully, enough power is used to penetrate through the pastern bone to visualize the navicular bone. Again, in this image, I have the navicular bone marked with a yellow arrow. Sometimes it can be hard to see, but hopefully we can see it in thisview. Overall, what we are looking for in this view is overall shape, thickness and defect evaluation. This particular image is not ideal, but is pretty close to normal from my view point and this particular horse did not demonstrate any lameness at the time of the x-ray.
Navicular disease is very common in more stocky breeds such as the QH or Appaloosa, in which the horse may be actually carrying more weight on the front limbs. It is also very common in horses with a foot that is too small genetically speaking or trimmed too small in relation to body size. Hoof conformation also plays a major role in the syndrome development and the general conformation of long toe, low heel actually predisposes to this condition more readily. The actual cause of the condition is not completely understood, but we do know that the above influences play a major role. Essentially what is happening is that the navicular bone is degenerating due to perceived decreased blood circulation. Pain is encountered due to this deterioration process. Now, what causes the decreased blood circulation? Excessive strain on the bone due to low heels, too small of a foot in relation to body size, increased concussive forces as well as possible genetic factors all play a role. The decreased blood circulation leads to obvious inflammation, which then contributes to bone resorption and remodeling. In some cases, the bone can fracture due to weakness.
These horses can present for a wide range of lameness varying from very mild to very obvious. In some cases, the owners have detected a change in gait or overall movement and can’t quite pin point down where the issue is originating. In other instances, maybe there is a decreased performance, decreased times in various events or an obvious lameness or reluctance to pick up a gait. Navicular horses are reluctant to put excessive weight on their front heels. When you watch them walk, they are generally stiff, don’t reach forward very well having a shortened anterior stride. When they turn, they will shift their weight to the rear limbs, much like a laminitic horse. If you force them to trot or canter, their stride is generally short and choppy.
On physical exam, some of them are quite painful. Often they will have an increased digital pulse to one or both feet. Hoof testers are commonly very positive in the heel region which helps to locate the source of pain. Evaluation of the hoof conformation also is generally a tell tale indicator, as most of them have low heels and overriding the shoes if they are shod.
Diagnostics include not only a physical examination, but also x-rays to determine if there is degeneration present. Nerve blocks are also performed to locate the source of pain. Sometimes, ultrasounds as well as venograms are performed.
This is the AP or front view of the navicular bone. Again, I have the bone indicated by a yellow arrow. What we are looking for is changes in shape, thickness of the cortical wall as well as any evident degeneration. In this particular horse, I have two red arrows pointing towards the front border of the navicular bone. Here we can appreciate a roughening of the bone border as well as small, black holes that are present within the bone, which indicated bone loss or degeneration. I often refer to these as “lollipop” lesions as their is usually a black “stick” as well as black “head” to the sucker lesion. This particular horse was not that bad in terms of lameness, but there was evident degeneration on x-ray.
A diagnosis of navicular disease is not an end, but one does have to realize that it is not reversible but can be managed in most instances. First, we have to look at the hoof conformation and correct it with proper trimming and shoe application, when needed. Understand that the DDFT is coursing on the back side of the navicular bone and if the heel is too low, then the tendon is stretched and puts excessive pressure upon the bone, which may compromise blood flow and overall health. The same holds true for a large horse with little feet. In those cases, the heel region is not of adequate size to withstand the weight of the horse. In cases of low heels, we will often times apply wedge heel shoes to take the strain off of the DDFT. In other cases, one may choose an eggbar shoe, which allows the horse to distribute more weight caudally beyond the heel region to the shoe, which relieves pressure.
In many cases, we will use NSAID medications such as bute to help reduce inflammation and pain, but we have to understand that these medications are only addressing a small portion of the inflammatory response as we have discussed before. Some vets will use Isoxsuprine which is intended to increase blood circulation. Others will use Pentoxifylline, which increases the flexibility of the red blood cells and potentially allows them to squeeze into tight spaces delivering oxygen. Both of these medications are used heavily in humans with poor circulation and do a good job, however, personally I have not witnessed tremendous benefit in horses.
In severe cases, navicular bursal injections of corticosteroids may be performed. The intent here is to deliver the medication very close to the bone. Again, we are not solving any problems with this treatment in my opinion and just buying time through mild inflammation reduction. In some cases, cold laser therapy or shock therapy may be employed, with mixed results. The last ditch effort has always been a surgical procedure called a neurectomy, which is a severing of the nerve to the region resulting in a loss of sensation to the heel region. Obviously, there are no therapeutic effects here, but we are just long term numbing the region. There can be some serious side effects to this procedure, sometimes with the horse ending up worse than what they were before the procedure.
Understanding the cause of the condition is paramount to managing it in a better way. Genetics do play a major role in navicular disease and it is most prominent in the QH breed, however many others are prone to the condition with increased work. The combination of improper weight distribution with poor hoof angles stimulates and inflammatory response within the tissue due to high levels of strain and stress.
We know that the inflammatory process plays a major role in navicular disease, contributing not only to pain production but also bone deterioration and degeneration. Cellular signaling is often enhanced in a negative way, which contributes to bone resorption and subsequent weakening of the structure. Even with therapies including NSAIDs, blood circulation modifiers, local steroid injections and even neurectomies, the condition continues to progress and if left unchecked, other surrouding tissues and structures can become involved, which makes matters worse.
At Nouvelle Research, our focus is on the inflammatory process and finding ways to control it and return it to a more normal level. Curcumin, Boswellia, Ashwaghanda, vitamin C and many other herbs and nutrients have been shown to help control the process at a much higher level than traditional medications and therapies. Curcumin, in research studies, has been shown to impact the cells responsible for bone resorption (osteoclasts), which may help to slow degeneration. Curcumin has also been shown to enhance blood circulation through reduction of inflammation and free radical damage. Through targeted use of these herbs, it is possible to create a better end result for the patient, helping to control the process and improving lameness scores. Dependent on the individual case, herbs can yield results by themselves or through their use, they can enhance the effects of various medications.
In our clinical experience, if we manage the inflammatory process more completely in combination with trimming and proper shoeing, the patient’s return to soundness is much quicker and more complete, often yielding a longer period of comfort and return to activity.
Navicular disease is a common and serious condition. If caught early enough, I feel that may horses can do very well with long term changes. Hoof conformation as well as body size of the horse are major players in the development of the disease and one must be conscious of how their horse is trimmed and shod at all times. I agree that there is a blood circulation issue at the root of the problem, but also believe that the inflammatory process plays a major role.
In terms of my patients and herbal therapies, I have found tremendous benefit in supporting hoof growth through the use of nutritive herbs including spirulina, pea protein, flax seed and alfalfa. I feel that in many instances, if we can support hoof growth through nutrient provision, we can potentially rebuild the heel region and thereby reduce strain from the flexor tendon. I also believe, that through nutrient provision, we are also enhancing blood circulation and bone health. These nutritive herbs, when used in combination with anti-inflammatory herbs such as Curcumin and boswellia, seem to produce some nice results in the long term.
The antioxidants and nutritive herbs in the formulas we use help to combat free radical damage to blood vessels as well as surrounding tissue, plus provide many nutrients that aid in overall health. Interesting enough, curcumin has been shown in several research studies to impact bone remodeling and degeneration by affecting osteoclast activity. Overall, our findings have been that the Cur-OST® formulas can help to improve quality of life, overall function and reduce pain for many of these patients.
Here is a video of an Appaloosa mare that has navicular disease and responded well to Cur-OST.
I hope that this information helps to explain this debilating condition in horses. Although it is very common, I do feel there are many options to enhance recovery and overall soundness for these patients, freeing them to live a more productive life.
All my best,
Tom Schell, D.V.M.
Nouvelle Research, Inc.